The issue of readers’ expectations cropped up in my earlier post ‘The Ins and Outs of Writing Character’ in relation to keeping your protagonist in character rather than out of it.
However, readers’ expectations also play an important part when it comes to structuring scenes to create tension in your novel.
As a general guideline, if you set up your reader to expect a certain development, event or revelation in a scene, you must deliver in some form or other, or risk incurring their (wholly righteous) anger and annoyance.
Of course, this doesn’t mean that you have to tell the reader everything immediately. Revealing character secrets bit by bit is an essential part of building tension, and keeping your reader engaged. But one of the structural problems I come across as a substantive editor is what I call the ‘unfulfilled promise’ syndrome, which usually shows up when an author is trying to create tension by drawing out, say, a confrontation or the revelation of a secret over a number of scenes.
To illustrate my point, let’s bring in Simon and Julia from my earlier post in relation to Point of View shifts:
Simon made his way to the greenhouse. Julia was alone at last. He would tell her now. That it was over. Them. After twenty-five years, three children, five dogs and a grandchild. He would do it now, while she was alone. She looked up at him as he reached the greenhouse door.
‘There you are, darling. Almost finished here. I’ll be in shortly.’
He gulped.
‘Julia? ‘
‘Yes?’
Simon decided he wouldn’t do it. Not yet.
‘Eh… I’m making a cup of tea, do you want one?’
‘Oh, yes, please.’
As a reader, this encounter leaves me feeling dissatisfied and a little cheated. And asking some awkward questions. Why did Simon say he was going to tell Julia their relationship was over and then decide not tell her after all? What caused him to change his mind? And what exactly was the point of that scene?
So how do you build tension without giving everything away at once? The answer is the same way you keep your character ‘in character’: by managing your reader’s expectations, not simply walking away from them or changing the subject at the crucial moment.
Let’s look at our Simon and Julia scene once again. What we need to do is to make it clear to the reader why Simon doesn’t go through with his intention of telling Julia their marriage is over. So why doesn’t he? Remember objectives and obstacles in The Terrible Twos? What if Simon’s objective is to tell Julia of the break-up while she’s alone, but just as he is about to do so, someone else arrives:
‘Julia? ‘
‘Yes?’
A loud bark from their excitable cocker spaniel and the sound of a small car pulling into the driveway alerted Simon to the fact that their two youngest daughters had returned from their shopping trip rather earlier than expected.
Now was not the time, after all.
‘Eh… I’m making a cup of tea, do you want one?’
Or perhaps the obstacle is internal: to do with the type of man Simon is. Perhaps he simply hasn’t the bottle to go through with it, or he shies away from conflict, or perhaps he still loves Julia deep down, and just can’t bring himself to do it. You’re the author, it’s your character, you choose. But whatever you choose, please keep the reader in the loop.
‘Julia?’
‘Yes?’
Simon hesitated. The thought of his wife’s distress at what he was about to say made him feel sick. No, he couldn’t do it. Not now. Not while she was alone, with no one to comfort her. He’d wait until their daughter, Poppy, arrived. Yes, that would be better. He’d wait until Poppy was here, then he’d do it.
‘Eh… I’m making a cup of tea, do you want one?’
So by fulfilling the promise set up in the scene, you not only gain a wonderful opportunity to impart some great character information, you also keep your readers engaged and wondering what will happen next.
Of course, if you really want to make it interesting, you could try this:
‘Eh… I’m making a cup of tea, do you want one?’
For a moment Simon thought he saw a look of dark suspicion cross Julia’s face. But then she smiled sweetly at him.
‘Oh, yes, please.’
Dah, dah, dah….